All Council Meetings

City of Sioux City Council Meeting - March 9, 2026

The Sioux City Council held a lengthy meeting dominated by public concern over proposed library budget cuts. The council clarified that they have been requesting the library develop a model for operating four neighborhood branches with a smaller downtown footprint, which the library board has not provided since September 2025. Three budget cut proposals remain under consideration ($300K, 25%, and $1M), with final budget decisions scheduled for March 18th wrap-up and April adoption. The council also approved appointments to several boards, extended a billboard moratorium by six months, and heard updates on city communications.

Key Decisions12
  • •Extended billboard moratorium by six months to develop regulations for off-premise signs after being approached by seven sign companies
  • •Approved first reading and waived rules for ordinance extending billboard moratorium
  • •Appointed Katherine Fappel to Active Transportation Advisory Committee (waiving policy against serving on multiple boards)
  • •Appointed Alex Waters to Active Transportation Advisory Committee
  • •Appointed Dean Bradham, Jose Montes, and Andrew Pritchard to Wastewater Treatment Plant Reconstruction and Fine Advisory Committee
  • •Approved consulting services agreement with Black and Beach for comprehensive wastewater treatment plan and environmental audit
  • •Approved consulting services agreement with DGR Engineering for Pulaski Park stormwater pipe replacement project
  • •Approved plans and specifications for annual sidewalk program project
  • •Accepted lease proposal from Ozac Commercial Properties for 124 Pierce Street property
  • •Approved change orders and payments for bridge overlays, sidewalk ramp, and Glen Oaks Boulevard paving projects
  • •Scheduled hearings on proposed property tax levy and multiple general obligation capital loan note propositions
  • •No final decision made on library budget — three proposals remain under consideration ($300,000 cut, 25% cut, or $1 million cut over time)
Topics Discussed12
Library budget proposals and public responseRequest for library to develop four-branch neighborhood model since September 2025Billboard moratorium extension and off-premise sign regulationsAppointments to Wastewater Treatment Plant Reconstruction Advisory CommitteeAppointments to Active Transportation Advisory CommitteeHonors for Bob and Julie Mesmer (bus driver and foster parents)National Brain Injury Awareness Month proclamationInfrastructure projects: sidewalk program, Pulaski Park stormwater, bridge overlaysProperty lease at 124 Pierce StreetDigital accessibility standards for city website and communicationsCity communications platforms update (social media, website redesign, Code Red alerts)Budget process timeline (March 18 wrap-up, April adoption)
Public Comments15
  • —Legend Campbell urged protecting library funding, citing 239,763 visitors and 320,000 items circulated saving residents over $3 million
  • —Linda Sante argued downtown library building is structurally suited for book collections and should remain the main branch
  • —Brandi Steck emphasized library's role in community building, especially for families
  • —Mary Nissan questioned what would actually be cut from library budget and requested clear public information
  • —Terry O'Brien cited previous study showing moving library wasn't fiscally sound since city owns the building, and noted Sioux Falls libraries all own their buildings
  • —JJ Stone raised concerns about SSDI/SSI recipients in nonprofit housing being denied rent reimbursement
  • —Ben Bemis (library employee) noted $3.03M of library budget is compensation, making cuts without staffing reductions impossible
  • —Teresa Becker emphasized importance of maintaining physical book collections including historical materials
  • —Charles Wishman (Iowa Federation of Labor president) urged protecting library staff jobs and emphasized library's role in workforce development access
  • —William Burroughs opposed any library cuts and criticized three-minute time limits on public comment
  • —Brett Watchworn questioned why library faced 25% cut proposals when other departments did not
  • —Andrew Losswald (fiscal committee member) distributed 15-page community library model proposal showing downtown costs $646/hour vs. $187/hour for Morningside
  • —Corey Davis (local 7103 CWA president) clarified that downtown budget reflects management costs distributed across all branches
  • —Maria Canchola stated willingness to pay higher property taxes rather than cut library services
  • —Paul Koskovich requested inclusion in billboard company discussions and faster moratorium resolution

Library Budget Debate Takes Center Stage

The March 10, 2026 Sioux City Council meeting turned into a community forum on library funding, with dozens of residents packing the chambers to voice concerns about proposed cuts. What emerged was a story more complicated than the headlines suggested.

Councilmember Julie Schoenherr laid out the timeline: Last September, the Effective Fiscal and Public Policy Committee asked library director Helen Rigdon to model what four neighborhood library branches might look like, using the efficient Morningside branch ($450,000 annual operating cost) as a template. The idea? Keep a main downtown presence, maintain Morningside, and add branches on the west side and in the Floyd Corridor/Leeds area — all while reducing the downtown facility's footprint and the nearly $4 million budget that's heavily concentrated there.

According to Schoenherr, that model was never developed. "No action was taken by the library board or by the director," she said, despite multiple meetings and follow-ups through the fall. The council emphasized repeatedly that they never proposed closing branches or eliminating services — they wanted to see if distributing services across four locations could serve more residents while saving taxpayer dollars.

Three budget reduction proposals are currently on the table: $300,000, 25% (roughly $1 million), or $1 million over time. But nothing has been decided. Mayor Bob Scott was blunt: "The budget as in that book is not cut. It was proposals which any council member can make. The budget is not cut in that budget."

Councilmember Craig Berenstein hadn't committed to a position. Councilmember Ike Rayford stayed mostly quiet. The budget won't be finalized until the March 18th wrap-up session at 8:30 AM, followed by formal adoption the last Monday of April.

What Residents Said

The room was full of people who love the library — and weren't afraid to say so. Legend Campbell broke down usage numbers: 239,763 visitors last year, 320,000 items circulated, $3 million saved by residents who borrowed instead of bought. Paul Fritzmeyer talked about his grandkids dancing to banana songs from a library musician. Brandi Steck shared how the library gave her community when she returned to Sioux City with two young kids and a sick husband.

Linda Sante made a structural argument: the downtown building was built by First Federal with reinforced construction that can handle the weight of a large book collection — exactly what a main library needs. "I think I'm going to be satisfied with the library I have," she said, pushing back on the idea of shrinking it.

Terry O'Brien pointed out that the city already studied this five or six years ago and concluded it wasn't fiscally sound to move from a building the city owns. "If you've got to go rent four buildings, come back and tell us what the cost of that's gonna be because it's not gonna be sound," she said.

Several speakers emphasized that the $3.7 million downtown operating budget includes all administrative overhead, management, and staff who rotate between branches — making direct comparisons to Morningside's $450K misleading.

Andrew Pritchard, who serves on the fiscal committee, distributed a 15-page alternative plan he'd developed showing how four branches could work. He noted that downtown costs $646 per operating hour versus $187 for Morningside, and that upcoming capital needs ($2.4M for downtown HVAC, $1.6M for Morningside parking) make this the right time to rethink the model.

Charles Wishman, president of the Iowa Federation of Labor, drove six hours round-trip to urge the council to protect library staff. "People love their librarians," he said. "Whatever budget you go ahead with, make sure that you try and do this without cutting staff."

The Blame Game

Councilmember Rick Bertrand didn't mince words about media coverage: "The media in this last seven, eight days has absolutely been pathetic." He argued that inflammatory reporting created panic when the council was simply trying to have a policy discussion.

He was equally critical of outgoing library director Helen Rigdon, who retires next month: "If she was in my company and her performance this week she'd be unemployed." (Rigdon did not attend the meeting and council members noted she doesn't report to them under Iowa library law.)

Councilmember Greg Berenstein emphasized waiting for the new library director: "I for one believe that it is necessary to wait till the new library director is in place" to have this discussion properly.

Several residents pushed back on the idea that the library ignored the council's request. The library board operates independently under state law, and the city's only leverage is funding. That structural tension — council controls the money, board controls operations — sat at the heart of the impasse.

What's Actually At Stake

The library's proposed FY2027 budget shows $3.03 million in compensation alone. Staff pointed out that cutting $1 million without cutting positions is mathematically impossible. The Morningside model works because it operates with 3.43 FTEs and relies on downtown for supplies, collections, and administrative support.

No decisions were made tonight. The March 18th wrap-up will show where council members actually land. Mayor Scott noted that property taxes are projected to go down this year despite budget pressures, and that every department faced scrutiny, not just the library.

One thing became clear: Sioux City residents will show up when they think something they value is threatened. Whether that energy translates into a better library model or just preserves the status quo remains to be seen.

Other Business: Billboards, Brains, and Buses

Before the library consumed all the oxygen, council:

  • Extended the billboard moratorium another six months to develop better regulations after being approached by seven off-premise sign companies wanting to locate in Sioux City. The issue? Current code allows massive digital billboards to be placed on small parcels in strip mall parking lots as "on-premise" signs, overshadowing neighboring businesses.
  • Honored Bob and Julie Mesmer — Bob drove buses for 22 years and just retired at 90, Julie fostered 89 children over 20 years and adopted three. Their grandson and his wife adopted another, inspired by their example.
  • Proclaimed National Brain Injury Awareness Month, recognizing Opportunities Unlimited's work providing services to brain injury survivors and prevention programs like "Gotta Brain Get a Helmet" that gives free helmets to every second-grader in Siouxland.
  • Appointed three new members to the Wastewater Treatment Plant Reconstruction Advisory Committee: Dean Bradham (30 years plumbing experience), Jose Montes (Iron Workers Local 21 organizer and Northwest Iowa Building Trades president), and Andrew Pritchard (Cargill refinery superintendent who manages a pre-treatment plant).
  • Approved consent items including the annual sidewalk program, accepting a lease proposal for 124 Pierce Street from Ozac Commercial Properties, and numerous infrastructure payments and property sales.

The wrap-up hearing is March 18th at 8:30 AM. If you care about the library — or any other part of the city budget — that's when you need to be there.

— SUX

Watch the full meeting

Recap generated by SUX, the Siouxland AI Assistant.

This recap is AI-generated from the official meeting transcript. While we strive for accuracy, please verify important details before acting on them.

Version 2